Skip to the content

Welcome to Plymale Insurance Group

Plymale Insurance Group Provides Auto/Car Insurance, Home Insurance, and Business/Commercial Insurance to Bucyrus and All of Ohio

Get A Quote
  • 125 West Rensselaer Street
  • Bucyrus, Ohio 44820

(419) 562-3904

  • Office Hours
  • Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
  • Sat-Sun: Closed
  • 743 Harding Way West
  • Galion, Ohio 44833

(419) 468-2875

  • Office Hours
  • Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
  • Sat-Sun: Closed

Insurance Quotes

Read what satisfied customers have said about Plymale Insurance Group.

See All Reviews
See All Reviews

Plymale Insurance Group - Bucyrus, Ohio

Auto/Car Insurance, Home Insurance, and Business/Commercial Insurance for Bucyrus and All of Ohio

A third generation owner, Lee Plymale continues to bring the same service that you have come to expect since the business opened over 75 years ago. Lee and fellow Agent Brad Seibert have the ability to find the most competitive rate with the professional insurance companies they do business with. Including ERIE Insurance, Motorists Mutual, Ohio Mutual Insurance, Progressive, and many others. You can be assured that this competition will bring you the best value that fits your individual insurance needs. For Auto, Home, Commercial, and Life visit us at our Bucyrus or Galion location to start your policies today.

Quotes From Multiple Insurance Companies

Recent News and Updates

When Should Small Business Owners Switch Insurance Companies?

Posted: April 19, 2025

When Should Small Business Owners Switch Insurance Companies?

Managing a small business comes with endless challenges—and great rewards. One of the main issues is keeping your overhead as low as possible. The cost of your business insurance should be reviewed yearly—savings could be possible. If you’ve been with the same insurance provider for years, you might assume you’re getting the best deal—but are you? Switching insurance companies can improve coverage, lower costs, and...

The Hidden Costs of Skipping Insurance

Posted: April 16, 2025

The Hidden Costs of Skipping Insurance

This April is the 22nd anniversary of Financial Literacy Month, a time that inspires us to secure our future with sound financial planning, budgeting, saving, and investing. It’s an excellent opportunity to improve your financial education and be more secure in your goals. For example, many people are unaware of the hidden costs of skipping insurance, making them financially vulnerable. Why Consider the Cost of...

6 Reasons Why Water Heaters Fail

Posted: April 8, 2025

6 Reasons Why Water Heaters Fail

It’s no fun going without hot water. That’s especially true when the seasons change and temperatures take a dip. But like nearly every otherappliance in your house, water heaters fail. And that can lead to cold showers — or even worse, a water leak. Here are 6 telltale signs you have a failing water heater: You only have cold water. Your water gets warm, but never hot....